Looking for the best pizza in Dayton, Ohio? Dayton has a serious pizza scene — from legendary old-school shops to modern wood-fired favorites. Below are the top 10 pizza places in Dayton, ranked by reviews, local buzz, consistency, and overall vibe.
Each spot includes ⭐ ratings, pizza style, vibe, what locals say, and a direct website link.
1. 🍕 Joe’s Pizzeria
⭐ Reviews: 4.7 / 5
Style: Classic Midwest pizza
Vibe: Old-school, family-run Dayton legend
What people say: “Best pizza in Dayton,” “loaded toppings,” “worth the wait.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
A Dayton institution for decades. Thick layers of cheese, generous toppings, and a nostalgic dining room make Joe’s a must-visit.
Website: https://joes-pizzadayton.com/
2. 🍕 Old Scratch Pizza
⭐ Reviews: 4.5 / 5
Style: Wood-fired, Neapolitan-inspired
Vibe: Trendy, social, craft-beer friendly
What people say: “Amazing crust,” “creative toppings,” “great beer selection.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
Wood-fired pies with seasonal ingredients in a lively taproom setting — perfect for date night or groups.
Website: https://www.oldscratchpizza.com/
3. 🍕 Dewey’s Pizza
⭐ Reviews: 4.7 / 5
Style: Gourmet American pizza
Vibe: Energetic, modern, upbeat
What people say: “Creative combos,” “great salads,” “awesome atmosphere.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
Inventive pies, quality ingredients, and a fun soundtrack make Dewey’s a crowd favorite near UD.
Website: https://deweyspizza.com/location/university-of-dayton/
4. 🍕 Flying Pizza
⭐ Reviews: 4.6 / 5
Style: Traditional American
Vibe: No-frills, classic Dayton
What people say: “Consistent,” “great slices,” “true local favorite.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
A reliable downtown staple serving straightforward, satisfying pizza for lunch or takeout.
Website: http://www.theflyingpizza.com/
5. 🍕 Pizza Factory Dayton’s Original
⭐ Reviews: 4.6 / 5
Style: Classic Dayton-style
Vibe: Old-school neighborhood shop
What people say: “Always solid,” “great delivery,” “classic taste.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
Simple, dependable pizza that’s been feeding Dayton for years — especially popular for takeout.
Website: http://www.pizzafactory.biz/
6. 🍕 Old Dayton Pizza
⭐ Reviews: 4.7 / 5
Style: Flavor-forward artisan pizza
Vibe: Bar-pizza hidden gem
What people say: “Amazing flavor,” “underrated,” “great crust.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
Located inside Riverside Hideaway, this spot delivers bold flavors with a relaxed bar vibe.
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/olddaytonpizza
7. 🍕 South Park Pizza Tavern
⭐ Reviews: 4.5 / 5
Style: Tavern-style pizza
Vibe: Lively, neighborhood hangout
What people say: “Fun atmosphere,” “great pizza & drinks.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
A local favorite for pizza, beer, and social energy — great for evenings and weekends.
Website: https://southparkpizzatavern.com/
8. 🍕 Gionino’s Pizzeria
⭐ Reviews: 4.5 / 5
Style: Ohio-style chain pizza
Vibe: Family-friendly, casual
What people say: “Consistent,” “great sauce,” “solid crust.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
A dependable Ohio favorite with thick crusts, bold sauce, and plenty of topping options.
Website: https://gioninos.com/
9. 🍕 Tandoori Crust Pizza
⭐ Reviews: 4.6 / 5
Style: Indian-fusion pizza
Vibe: Casual, unique, bold flavors
What people say: “One-of-a-kind,” “incredible spices,” “unexpectedly amazing.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
Traditional pizza meets Indian spices — a standout option if you want something different near Dayton.
Website: https://tandooricrustpizza.com/
10. 🍕 Pizza Dive
⭐ Reviews: 4.4 / 5
Style: Classic pizza & comfort food
Vibe: Relaxed, budget-friendly
What people say: “Good value,” “casual vibe,” “great for families.”
Pizza & atmosphere:
Affordable pizzas, pretzels, and subs in a laid-back setting — perfect for easy dinners.
Website: https://www.pizzadive.com/
🍕 Final Word: Best Pizza in Dayton, Ohio
Dayton’s pizza scene blends tradition, creativity, and local pride. Whether you’re craving:
- Old-school classics
- Wood-fired artisan pies
- Tavern pizza & beer
- Or something totally unique
These top 10 pizza places in Dayton, Ohio consistently deliver.